Discussion of wealth taxation in the age of AI billionaires
Read more
Egypt Independent
www.egyptindependent.com

Discussion of wealth taxation in the age of AI billionaires

Amid growing discontent over the concentration of power and wealth, as well as the shrinking middle class, some states are beginning to implement various forms of taxes on wealthy citizens who have accumulated vast fortunes through artificial intelligence.

New York is planning to introduce an additional annual tax on expensive residential properties that are not the primary place of residence. Washington D.C. is considering implementing an investment income tax for wealthier households. The state of Washington intends to introduce its first modern income tax for households whose income exceeds $1 million in 2028.

California's Proposition 40, aimed at a 'billionaire tax,' failed on election day. However, Senator Chris Van Hollen (D-MD) told Politico that the failure of Prop 40 indicates that one state cannot solve this problem alone. A bill already introduced in the House and Senate proposes a 5% tax on the net capital of American billionaires, which could be a turning point in the 2028 presidential election.

The failure of Prop 40 and the sudden emergence of a new AI elite class have sparked more intense national discussions about how exactly the rich should be taxed.

Not so much cash flow as paper capital

Anderson Lafontaine, Managing Director of Blue Zone Wealth Advisors, noted that having assets worth $1 billion does not mean a person has $50 million in cash to pay taxes. He explained that a significant portion of net capital often exists only on paper. For example, companies going public have restrictions on shareholder stock sales after listing, so an employee may not have a large amount of liquid funds until they sell their shares.

Prop 40 proposed a one-time 5% tax on the net capital of billionaires residing in California as of January 1, 2026, excluding real estate and most retirement accounts. Tom Steyer, a climate activist billionaire and former California gubernatorial candidate, emphasized that the essence of a wealth tax is that it targets paper wealth. He also suggested that a person could take out a loan against stocks to pay taxes, calling Prop 40 'imperfect,' but 'better than nothing.'

Tension with wealthy citizens

Megan Lisa Jones, a private equity and tax lawyer at Holland & Knight, reported that some of her clients have either left California or are discussing moving there in search of more favorable tax rates and to avoid potential Prop 40. Lafontaine also mentioned that some of his clients have moved for tax reasons, although this is not necessarily related to the wealth tax. Both specialists noted that their high-income clients did not wish to comment to CNN.

Jones added that some of her clients might say, 'I can't leave now, but I will in four years... and I'm not a billionaire yet, so I'm not worried about it.' However, she warned that if billionaires start being taxed, it is only a matter of time before it spreads and affects everyone. Steyer advocates for a national wealth tax so that the wealthy do not continue to migrate in search of tax havens. He stated, 'I am not angry at people for being rich. It's just that people suffer greatly on the other side.'

The elected Governor of California, Javier Becerra, called Prop 40 'questionable policy' and stated that the state needs to find a long-term solution instead of a one-off measure. His press secretary told CNN in a statement that the success of Prop 3, a state measure making additional taxes on high-income workers permanent, proves the support of California voters for taxing the wealthy.

Beyond the Golden State

Washington state voters supported the so-called 'millionaire tax' on election day, according to which any income over $1 million will be taxed. This means that a couple earning over $500,000 each will be taxed as millionaires. Currently, Washington state has no income tax. This 9.9% tax will take effect in 2028, pending constitutional challenges.

This prompted Michelle Dellino, a family law attorney in Seattle, to advise her clients to carefully consider important life decisions. She noted that some of these decisions—such as marriage, signing a prenuptial agreement, or moving—cannot be easily undone.

Furthermore, some of her clients may face a 'scary' tax bill when company stock vests entirely to the employee and is taxed as salary, even if the employee has no cash from selling those shares.

What 'wealth' really means

The rising cost of living nationwide calls into question whether millionaire status retains the same financial significance it once had. For instance, an analysis by JanusGroup Real Estate showed that the median family home in Seattle sold for approximately $1.1 million in October. Lafontaine believes that asset owners in America benefit, while those without assets are simply 'eaten by inflation.' If a 'wealth tax' is introduced, he would prefer that taxes be levied upon the sale of assets, rather than their ownership.

As AI transforms society, Jones raises a broader question about how American tax policy relies too heavily on ordinary income. She notes, 'If we don't have people working the same way, if AI truly replaces jobs, then we will have another big problem with our tax system and how we fund necessities.'

Similar stories

California residents reject wealth tax proposal for multimillionaires
Read more
noticiasaominuto.com

California residents reject wealth tax proposal for multimillionaires

Voters in California, located in the southwestern United States, rejected an unprecedented proposal for taxing the net capital of multimillionaires after heated debates involving major technology leaders.

This rejection was a victory for democratic leaders who opposed the measure, including Governor Gavin Newsom, who could potentially run for President of the United States in 2028. Critics of the tax, known as Proposition 40, argued that the measure would force ultra-wealthy taxpayers to leave the state.

Most California residents vote by mail, and any postcard ballot dated before election day is counted provided it arrives within a week. Because of this, it often takes days or even weeks to determine the results of intense debates.

The Associated Press (AP) reported on Monday that the 'no' vote did not receive enough votes to win.

The 'no' campaign raised approximately ten times more financial resources than the 'yes' side. Only Sergey Brin, co-founder of the tech giant Google, donated more than $100 million (€89 million) to the political committee opposing the measure.

The proposal called for a flat 5% tax on the wealth of California residents whose net worth exceeds one billion dollars (€891 million). Most of the collected funds were intended to compensate for federal healthcare funding cuts, while 10% was designated for education and food assistance programs.

The union SEIU United Healthcare Workers West, which supported the measure, stated that it was necessary to replenish about $100 billion that the state would lose from federal healthcare funds over the next five years.

Proposition 40 became the largest test to date of an idea long promoted by progressives: increasing taxes on the ultra-rich by focusing on their primary source of income—investments—rather than the wages they earn from work.

The measure received support from progressive leaders outside the state, including Vermont Senator Bernie Sanders, who participated in rallies in various California cities during the final weeks of the campaign, urging voters to approve it.

An AP poll showed that most young California voters under 30 voted 'yes'. Older voters were significantly less inclined: about seven out of ten voters aged 65 and older reported voting 'no'. Gavin Newsom argues that the property tax in California will put the state at a disadvantage, yet he supports a minimal national tax for any individual with net worth over $100 million.

Popular