Discussion on the fairness of the new commission for sellers in the UPI system
Read more
YourStory [india, en]
yourstory.com

Discussion on the fairness of the new commission for sellers in the UPI system

The UPI system has never been free, but questions have arisen regarding the fairness of introducing a new commission for merchants. Since any network processing trillions of rupees monthly requires funding, the key issue is determining who will bear the costs and how.

For six years, funding was provided through government subsidies, bank technology budgets, and reduced savings interest rates for depositors. As RBI Governor Sanjay Malhotra noted, 'Even now it is not free; someone pays for it.' The new Merchant Discount Rate (MDR) makes this cost evident.

In the financial year 26, UPI processed over 24,000 crore transactions worth approximately 314 lakh crore rupees ($3.31 trillion USD), and from April to September 2026, 14,500 crore transactions worth 177 lakh crore rupees ($1.86 trillion USD). According to the IMF, UPI processes about half of global real-time payments by volume.

In July, the Bank for International Settlements (BIS) indicated that fast payment systems with zero user fees and mandatory participation are growing rapidly, but private companies managing them face revenue challenges.

Compared to some international payment systems, UPI's MDR is 0.4% for payments over 2,000 rupees, which is lower than Indonesia's QRIS (0.7% for large merchants) and Chinese wallets (around 0.6%), and closer to Brazil's Pix (approximately 0.22–0.33%), and significantly less than credit card fees. In India, sellers receiving up to 1 lakh rupees per month pay no fees, while railway, fuel, utility, and insurance services are subject to a fixed rate of 5 rupees.

The commission in India is free up to 2,000 rupees ($21 USD), which is about four times more than in Indonesia. According to NPCI, over 96% of merchant transactions by volume remain free. For example, a seller receiving 75,000 rupees via NEFT pays nothing, whereas the same amount via UPI would cost 300 rupees plus GST.

In August 26, the volume of UPI merchant payments reached approximately 8.95 lakh crore rupees ($94 billion USD), of which about 6 lakh crore rupees ($63 billion USD) exceeded the 2,000 rupee threshold. Considering sectors with a fixed rate of 5 rupees and the set limit, the effective rate is approximately 0.15–0.20%, generating an annual pool of about 12,500 crore rupees ($1.32 billion USD). Under the current formula, banks receive 40%, acquirers 30%, applications 20%, and PSP payers/sponsor banks connecting apps to UPI 10%. Banks could potentially receive 60 to 70%.

According to the BIS bulletin, PhonePe and Google Pay currently control about 80% of the user-facing market. Together, they could collect around 2,100 crore rupees ($221 million USD) annually. BIS notes that when the market is concentrated in the hands of a few players, mere interoperability may not be enough to restore equitable distribution.

NPCI announced a 30% volume cap for any single application in November 2020, but this decision has been postponed three times and remains unimplemented after six years because it proved difficult to divert customers.

An IMF note states that payments provide large tech firms with stable income and data for selling credit and other services. This commission, intended to cover incurred costs, will ultimately fund the broader ambitions of the two leaders. Another aspect is the 18% GST, which applies only to the MDR, not the total payment amount. At the maximum limit, the merchant pays 354 rupees. Registered sellers can reclaim this amount as input tax credit. The real cost falls on those sellers who cannot reclaim this GST—for instance, composite dealers and tax-exempt goods sellers.

Shifting costs to the customer will not stop price increases by sellers; a buyer of a 500 rupee charger might end up paying for a 50,000 rupee phone. Furthermore, charging even 5 rupees for single loan repayments over 2,000 rupees, after many years of microfinance borrowers moving away from cash, is a regressive step. Banning surcharges will not prevent stores from raising prices, so a buyer of a 500 rupee charger is unknowingly helping to pay for a 50,000 rupee phone.

The author proposes setting the commission at 100 rupees (pre-2020) and reviewing it every two years based on audited cost data, similar to how the US Federal Reserve does for debit cards. BIS points out that such data is currently unavailable, and banks and NPCI must address this immediately.

It is suggested that the RBI, rather than NPCI, should set the rate, as is done for debit cards, NEFT, and RTGS. NPCI belongs to the banks that collect the majority of the commission. The share of applications should also be reduced as volumes grow so that the largest players earn less per transaction, and the RBI should be allowed to set levels after public consultations. Unlike volume caps, this reduction works through pricing.

It is also proposed that information on who received how much from payments be published annually. The 5-rupee fee for loan repayment should be abolished, as repayment is not a purchase. Acquiring banks should be held accountable for surcharges, and the limits of 2,000 rupees and 1 lakh rupees should be increased considering inflation. NPCI postponed implementation after Diwali, and a public petition is before the Supreme Court. This time should be used to correct the structure itself, not to re-debate the necessity of charging fees. UPI has gained the trust of hundreds of millions of Indians due to its simplicity and fairness, and its price must meet this same criterion.

Similar stories

RBI grants Paytm relief: company must undergo system audit within 6 months or approval will be revoked
Read more
www.aajtak.in

RBI grants Paytm relief: company must undergo system audit within 6 months or approval will be revoked

One97 Communications, the parent company of Paytm, has managed to receive significant relief regarding its return to the digital wallet business sector. Its subsidiary, Paytm Payments Services Limited (PPSL), received in-principle approval from the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) to issue prepaid payment instruments (PPIs), i.e., digital wallets.

However, even after receiving this permission, customers cannot immediately start using the new wallets. The company must fulfill several mandatory conditions set by the RBI. The most crucial requirement is the submission of a system audit report within the next six months. The company announced this information on November 13. This approval was issued by the RBI in accordance with the Payment and Settlement Systems Act of 2007, paving the way for PPSL to offer not only digital wallets but also other prepaid payment instruments.

Previously, Paytm indicated in its first quarter reports for the fiscal year 2026-27 that its subsidiary had applied for a wallet license. Receiving in-principle approval from the RBI significantly boosted the company's hopes for progress in this area.

Receiving approval from the RBI does not mean that Paytm will immediately start issuing new digital wallets. Currently, the company has only been granted in-principle approval. This allows it to move forward in the process of obtaining the final license. In its letter, the RBI clearly stated that PPSL can only issue new prepaid payment instruments after receiving the Certificate of Authorisation.

Therefore, until the company fulfills all necessary conditions and obtains final approval, the launch of a new wallet service line is impossible.

To obtain final approval, the RBI set a key condition for the company: Paytm Payments Services Limited must conduct an audit of its system with the assistance of a qualified auditor. This audit must comply with RBI directives concerning the security of digital payments and the strengthening of cyber systems. Indeed, on November 5, the RBI issued instructions to non-banking payment system operators regarding cybersecurity and digital payment control measures. The company is obliged to conduct a system audit in accordance with these rules.

The RBI has given the company six months to submit the audit report. This period starts counting from the date of receiving the RBI letter issued on November 13. Consequently, PPSL must submit the system audit report to the regulator within the stipulated period. If PPSL fails to provide the report on time, the in-principle approval it received will be automatically revoked. In such a case, the RBI will not consider granting the final license, making the next six months extremely critical for Paytm.

In addition to the system audit, the RBI has established other requirements. Paytm Payments Services Limited must comply with current RBI instructions regarding the storage of data related to the payment system. Furthermore, any changes in the company's share capital or ownership require prior approval from the RBI. Compliance with these rules is also part of the process of obtaining the final license.

Developing Inclusive Digital Payments for India: The PayU Experience
Read more
yourstory.com

Developing Inclusive Digital Payments for India: The PayU Experience

For digital payments to be effective in India, simply achieving the first transaction is not enough; the more complex task is ensuring user confidence that they will return, whether for online purchases in their preferred language, self-service payments, or running a small business.

At the TechSparks 2026 event, Sagar Kumar, Vice President of Engineering at PayU, participated in a discussion with Shivani Mutanna, Senior Director of Strategic Content and Video at YourStory, focusing on the engineering aspects of inclusive digital payments.

Kumar, with experience working in early-stage startups and on systems processing millions of transactions, explained how engineering priorities change as a business scales. In the initial stages, startup teams focus on speed, quickly launching products and learning along the way. However, architecture remains critical; loosely coupled systems simplify the addition of new business verticals without requiring a complete overhaul.

When reaching large scale, speed is still important, but the acceptable error rate decreases. Using feature flags, phased rollouts, and A/B testing allows teams to introduce changes gradually, test them on specific customer groups, and limit potential damage from issues.

He noted: 'Speed is a constant. It's just that as you grow into a larger ecosystem, the margin for error shrinks, and in this process, you need to build sufficient safety systems.'

Since UPI is already familiar to many users in small towns and villages, Kumar believes the next step should be to give online payments the same intuitiveness as offline transactions. PayU has configured its checkout pages by default to the scan and pay option, offering an experience similar to what customers are accustomed to in physical stores. Furthermore, the Checkout for Bharat feature was launched, which allows users to view checkout pages in multiple languages, easing the payment process for those less confident in English.

However, a simpler interface is only part of the solution. Kumar explained that for a first-time buyer, a payment error message after funds have been debited can quickly erode trust. He emphasized that payment systems require protective mechanisms, such as idempotency checks, which guarantee that resubmitting the same request will not alter the result after the first successful attempt. These checks help prevent double debits. Clear information about failed transactions and automatic refunds are also crucial so that customers do not have to request a refund themselves.

In Kumar's view, 'the next level of inclusivity is not about getting the first user online to pay, but about winning their confidence so they make another 100 payments. We design our systems to achieve this goal.'

In August, PayU released an RBI-compliant checkout page designed to assist blind and visually impaired users in making payments independently. The functionality includes vocalizing important information, such as payment amounts, seller details, and transaction status, using screen readers. The company also made changes to button sizes, text layouts, and other visual elements. PayU tested this user experience with blind and visually impaired users who were able to complete payments independently, without relying on anyone else. The company integrated accessibility into its software development lifecycle, considering it a factor alongside functionality and performance when developing new features.

Kumar pointed out that these improvements can benefit other users as well. For example, high-contrast displays make viewing payment pages easier for delivery partners in bright sunlight. Clearly defined interface elements can also help AI agents navigate checkout pages.

PayU processes approximately 20 million transactions on average per day. At this volume, even a 0.1% rejection rate can mean 20,000 failed payments. Kumar explained that the complexity of operating at this scale is due to the number of involved systems. A single transaction can depend on sellers, issuing and acquiring banks, payment networks, aggregators, and numerous gateways. A slowdown or failure in any of these systems can affect the payment. PayU uses intelligent routing to manage this complexity. The company's systems monitor gateway success metrics across various parameters, and machine learning models help determine the optimal route for each transaction. Algorithms also direct some transaction traffic through alternative routes to test their performance, giving the system insight into how different gateways are operating in real time. If a gateway's performance degrades, transactions can be rerouted to another option. Kumar reported that PayU has patented this routing algorithm. The goal is to manage these complexities in the background so that sellers and customers do not have to deal with them when conducting transactions.

Kumar also discussed how payment data can create opportunities beyond the transactions themselves. UPI payments generate transaction history, which helps businesses understand customer payment behavior and supports financial underwriting to meet certain credit needs. PayU's LazyPay product addresses Buy Now, Pay Later (BNPL) challenges, and its merchant lending product helps small and medium-sized businesses manage cash flow needs, including purchasing goods at better prices. Reimbursement can be collected through daily settlements. The company also launched Agent HQ, which helps small businesses automate operational tasks such as tracking website drop-offs, reconciling payments, and initiating refunds. By reducing the time founders spend on these activities, such tools allow them to focus on growing their business. For Kumar, the benefits extend beyond individual merchants: as small businesses grow, the entire broader digital payments ecosystem benefits.

Popular