A lawyer advocating for South Africa's requirement of a 30% stake for telecommunications licensees believes that the lawsuit filed by the Sakeliga business group has created a complex situation for the regulator Icasa.
This week, Sakeliga approached the Pretoria High Court requesting the cancellation of the ICT sector regulator's decision, which states that it cannot implement the political direction of Communications Minister Suli Malatsi regarding Equity Empowerment Investment Programmes (EEIPs) without legislative changes.
The EEIP programmes would allow multinational corporations, such as Elon Musk's Starlink, to invest in local enterprises and skills instead of selling 30% of their operations in South Africa to historically disadvantaged groups.
Lucien Pierce, a partner at PPM Attorneys, stated that despite his support for the 30% requirement for Historically Disadvantaged Groups (HDG), he believes Sakeliga has placed Icasa in a difficult position. He noted that he did not have time to review all the legal aspects of the case.
The core of the case lies in section 9(2)(b) of the Electronic Communications Act, which requires ownership by historically disadvantaged groups to be 'not less than 30% or such other conditions or a higher percentage as may be prescribed'. Sakeliga argues that the phrase 'or such other conditions' gives Icasa discretion.
Pierce interprets these words more narrowly, pointing out that the section was 'intended to maintain ownership at a level of not less than 30%'. However, he also finds merit in Sakeliga's argument that the Broad-Based Black Economic Empowerment Act (B-BBEE) takes precedence over the Electronic Communications Act, 'under a strict interpretation of the law'. This creates a conflict between the two acts that requires resolution, and amendments could provide clarity. 'Perhaps this is why Icasa claims an amendment is required,' he added.
Icasa's position is that it should consider only the minister's directives, not follow them. The regulator stated that it considered Malatsi's instruction, but the law prevents its implementation. Pierce noted: 'If Sakeliga is correct—that section 9(2)(b) allows Icasa to recognize EEIPs as 'other conditions'—then Icasa would be legally incorrect, and its decision could be reviewed.'
He considers Sakeliga's alternative argument, that the section is unconstitutional if Icasa's interpretation is correct, less convincing. Pierce emphasized that telecommunications, like mining, depends on a scarce national resource—the radio frequency spectrum. He suggested that having licensing provisions in the electronic communications sector similar to those established for mining licenses would not be unconstitutional.
Sakeliga's CEO, Piet le Roux, told the TechCentral Show on Friday that Icasa has 'clearly misinterpreted' the law. He added: 'No lawsuit is perfect, and no lawsuit is a silver bullet, but this lawsuit is much better than having no litigation process.'
Icasa must now provide the protocol of its decision. Le Roux explained: 'The type of application we filed here forces Icasa to show its cards. Once they provide this protocol, they cannot change it later….'
Sakeliga has not contacted Malatsi, who is mentioned as a respondent. Le Roux noted: 'We coordinated nothing and asked him for nothing, and I think that is appropriate.'
Resolution of BEE deals
When asked whether companies Vodacom, MTN, and Telkom, which have complied with the 30% rule for years, should be allowed to switch to EEIPs or terminate existing ownership agreements, Le Roux replied that deals concluded 'under duress for racial limitation purposes must be reviewable'. However, he clarified that 'it is not that simple', as each case must be considered individually because it is a 'mix of commercial contract and state coercion'.
Telkom informed Icasa in a submission first published by TechCentral that any new expansion rules must apply equally to all licensees. Le Roux stated that companies that complied with the rules should not insist on maintaining them: 'I do not think it is a justified argument to maintain a bad system because you were its victim.'
Who funds Sakeliga
Le Roux rejected online claims that Elon Musk or Starlink are funding the case. He said: 'I would be very happy to accept any contribution from him. But no, we are funded by local people.'
He reported that Sakeliga has over 8000 sponsors, and no single sponsor accounts for more than 5% of the total funding, although they do not publish their names. 'We have been fighting BEE long before Starlink became interested in expanding in South Africa.'
Sakeliga has previously won cases against other licensing regulators. In August 2025, the High Court ruled that domestic air travel licenses could not be tied to B-BBEE criteria, and in June, the same applied to international airlines. In September, the court declared the requirement for real estate agents to have a B-BBEE certificate unconstitutional.