Experts warn: seedling distribution is insufficient to combat drought under climate change conditions
Read more
Food For Mzansi
foodformzansi.co.za

Experts warn: seedling distribution is insufficient to combat drought under climate change conditions

The distribution of seedlings and tools is not a sufficient measure to counteract future droughts caused by hotter and drier conditions brought by El Niño in South Africa. In the context of COP31, dedicated to climate-resilient food systems, Simile Mikze from Tshikululu Social Investments explains why social investors should cease funding short-term results and begin investing in water security, reserve funds, and post-harvest support.

The thirty-first United Nations Climate Change Conference (COP31), which began in Turkey on November 9, includes food security as a priority topic in its Agenda for Action. This topic covers climate-resilient agriculture and strengthening the links between food and water management. Discussions at COP should prompt social investors to reconsider their approach.

This includes posing important questions such as: 'Will the food security programs we fund today help households eat well after the next drought, flood, or price shock?' The conference serves as a reminder and a call to action to consider household resilience to shocks as part of project design and to fund necessary support.

Food security means consistent access to sufficient and nutritious food over the long term. A successful harvest or food parcel meets an immediate need, but sustainable food security depends on what happens when rainfall stops, incomes disappear, or food prices rise.

According to the UN report on the state of food security and nutrition in the world for 2026, 645 million people faced hunger in 2025. Although this is almost 14 million fewer than in 2024, the figure remains alarmingly high.

Data from South African households show a worsening situation in the previous period: moderate and severe food insecurity increased from 15.8% of households in 2019 to 19.7% in 2023. These figures reflect different conditions and periods, but the trend in South Africa underscores the need for sustainable local action.

The issue of accessibility remains a central problem. In September 2026, the Group for Economic Justice and Dignity Pietermaritzburg set the cost of a food basket for seven people at approximately 5,488 rand, compared to 6,655 rand for a basic nutritious basket of the same size household. This gap reflects the discrepancy between what households buy and the cost of a complete diet. Growing vegetables helps, but it does not eliminate the need for sufficient income to purchase other foods.

As reflected in the priority items of the COP31 agenda, climate risks exacerbate existing pressures. On September 3, the World Meteorological Organization warned of intensifying El Niño, increasing the risks of drought, flooding, and extreme heat. The South African Weather Service's September forecast indicated hotter and drier conditions in many parts of the country in the coming months. These forecasts reinforce the arguments for more resilient food systems and better preparation for poor harvests.

This is where the focus of COP31 on sustainability must influence social investment decisions. Trialogue estimated South Africa's total corporate social responsibility spending at 13.1 billion rand in 2025. Their study showed that food security and agriculture accounted for an average of 13% of participating companies' CSR spending.

Funding organizations must ask what long-term protection this investment provides. Household gardening programs illustrate this problem. For a household that relies on a backyard garden for food and income, a crop failure creates a double burden: reduced food availability while simultaneously eliminating a source of income. Irrigation, savings, insurance, and credit provide protection where households have access to them. Without these resources, a weather shock quickly turns into a food and income crisis.

Seedlings, shade nets, shovels, rakes, and training can better prepare households for food production. Funding organizations provide these resources and track the number of gardens created, inputs distributed, and training sessions conducted. These results demonstrate delivery. They do not confirm that households will sustain production, improve diet, or recover from poor harvests after program support ends.

When funding stops at the creation stage, programs leave households to cope with risks threatening their progress. A garden without reliable water supply, input replacement, or practical follow-up support offers limited protection against a prolonged dry spell. Funding organizations must consider the costs of maintaining project outcomes when making investment decisions.

Work begins with planning. Program teams must assess households' access to water, income sources, available labor, care responsibilities, and vulnerability to local climate risks before intervention. They must agree with participants on what support is realistic and who will sustain it. Where households lack land, water, or time, a garden alone will not solve their food insecurity problem.

Agricultural support must be tailored to local conditions. Crop diversity, mulching, and water harvesting help households cope with dry conditions. Drainage, raised beds, and flood preparedness address other risks. Training must explain when and how to apply these methods, followed by support that helps households troubleshoot as conditions change.

Climate instability means that program implementation must be flexible and adaptable. Funding organizations must provide contingency budgets, allow flexibility in implementation timelines, and pre-agree on how beneficiaries will react to crop loss or household failures. Local support networks, savings groups, nutrition education, market access, and linkages to social assistance that complement agricultural inputs can help manage uncertainty.

Monitoring and evaluation must start with program planning and continue after the first harvest. Trialogue's 2025 study showed that 68% of surveyed companies had M&E policies, but only 36% allocated a specific budget for this work. Most of these allocations were 5% or less of CSR budgets. This puts funding organizations at a disadvantage for assessing outcomes and making informed decisions in the future.

In this context, a good M&E system involves establishing a baseline, tracking results across seasons, and studying what happens after shocks. Are households eating a wider range of nutritious foods? Has home production led to reduced food expenses? Does surplus produce generate income after deducting costs?

How quickly does production recover after a shock? Answers should guide changes in support, alongside manual activity reporting. These questions reflect the four dimensions of food security: availability, access, utilization, and stability. Food must exist, households must be able to obtain it, and diets, cooking practices, and health status must support good nutrition. These conditions must also be maintained over the long term.

The number of gardens created is only a partial measure of food security and cannot, by itself, demonstrate whether households are fed.

COP31 provides governments, businesses, and social investors with an opportunity to link climate commitments to household realities. The answer for funding organizations must include longer funding periods when necessary, budgets supporting adaptation and recovery, and metrics that track households after project completion.

The real test is whether households still have reliable access to nutritious food after the next unforeseen cost, flood, price spike, or drought. Investments in food security must pay for the conditions that make these achievements sustainable and viable in the long run. This is the standard that South African social investors must bring to the COP31 discussion.

Similar stories

Collaboration in the value chain is key to creating climate-resilient agriculture
Read more
foodformzansi.co.za

Collaboration in the value chain is key to creating climate-resilient agriculture

Weather intensification is being observed in South Africa and across the continent. Extreme weather events, such as El Niño, should no longer be viewed as isolated incidents but as recurring risks that demand a more adaptive and resilient agricultural sector.

In a statement, the company Omnia emphasized that the future of sustainable agriculture depends on the ability of countries to support the most climate-vulnerable producers so they can operate successfully in an increasingly uncertain environment.

Omnia notes that a sustainable agricultural sector is one where producers have access to the necessary information, expertise, and support to forecast weather shocks, respond effectively to them, and recover quickly afterward. The company added that building this resilience begins long before a crisis occurs, making access to agricultural knowledge and practical insights critical for long-term growth and sustainability.

According to Omnia, as weather volatility increases, resilience must become an integral part of agricultural success. Providing producers with adequate knowledge, methods, and technologies will be vital for managing risks, maintaining productivity, and strengthening food security in the long term.

Stefan Serfontein, CEO of Omnia, stated that extreme weather represents one of the most pressing environmental challenges facing the world, and it will always be relevant to Omnia. Serfontein clarified that sustainability in agriculture is too often viewed as a question of what producers should do differently. A more important question is what the broader agricultural value chain must provide to make those choices possible. Resilience cannot depend solely on producers coping with climatic instability themselves.

According to Serfontein, no single organization can solve this problem alone. Bridging the resilience gap will require coordinated action across the entire value chain:

  • Producers need detailed data analysis to make informed production decisions. This includes using historical data, seasonal forecasts, field-specific risk profiles, agronomic advice, and participation in knowledge-sharing initiatives that foster dialogue and best practices.
  • Agribusiness should increase the availability of climate information, advisory services, and agricultural technologies while investing in producer development and capacity building.
  • Governments must support agribusiness resilience by developing and expanding market access and strengthening local infrastructure. Climate change adaptation programs must also transform into practical support for producers. Partnerships between government, agribusiness, and producers are most effective when significant progress is made before crises strike.

Building resilience is fundamentally different from merely reacting to natural disasters.

Study shows excessive income diversification can negatively affect farmers with subsidy support
Read more
foodformzansi.co.za

Study shows excessive income diversification can negatively affect farmers with subsidy support

In agricultural development, it has long been considered common knowledge that households are in a better position when they have multiple sources of income. The principle of diversification implies risk distribution, which increases resilience. However, a study conducted in northeastern Zimbabwe indicates that this assertion is only partially true: after reaching a certain point, adding new activities can lead to household impoverishment.

Therefore, policymakers should focus on supporting and enabling diversification up to the point where it brings tangible benefits, by investing in suitable assets that justify each new activity.

The idea for this study arose from a broader concern. Across Sub-Saharan Africa, rural households are increasingly abandoning rain-fed agriculture as their primary means of subsistence. Reasons for this include climate change, declining yields, rising production costs, and stagnant producer prices.

Governments responded to this situation with programs providing subsidies for resources such as fertilizers and hybrid seeds, aiming to stabilize rural incomes. Nevertheless, most evaluations of these programs focus solely on increasing yield, ignoring the impact on the overall household livelihood strategy.

The authors wanted to find out whether resource subsidies truly help rural households improve their lives, or if they merely help them cope with difficulties. This study was part of the author's doctoral work in agricultural economics at Fort-Her University under the supervision of Professor Abbissini Musunge. The broader project aimed to examine the wider implications of resource subsidies and propose a scientifically sound model for livelihood support in Zimbabwe.

The study covered 408 households in the Mashonaland-East province between May and July 2024. Half of them were beneficiaries of the Pfumvudza resource subsidy program in Zimbabwe, and the other half were not. This program, launched in the 2020/21 season, provides farmers with free maize seeds, fertilizer, and lime provided they establish climate-smart conservation plots.

These plots must adhere to three principles of conservation agriculture: minimal soil disturbance, mulching with crop residues, and rotation with legumes. Pfumvudza is one of the government's key initiatives to stabilize incomes in a country with limited formal employment opportunities.

The researchers posed two questions: does receiving subsidized resources encourage households to diversify their lifestyles? And does this diversification lead to increased income? A statistical approach was used to measure diversification, which considers not only the number of activities a household engages in (e.g., crop cultivation, hiring labor, or running a small business) but also the evenness of income distribution among them.

Two significant findings were revealed. Firstly, resource subsidies do indeed promote diversification: beneficiaries had a more diverse livelihood portfolio compared to those who did not receive subsidies. Secondly, and this was more unexpected, additional diversification did not lead to increased income. Moreover, subsidy beneficiaries were in a worse position than non-beneficiary households.

Analysis of the causes revealed an inverted U-shaped relationship between diversification and household income. Income increases as households add income streams, but only up to a certain limit. Beyond this threshold, adding more activities is associated not with increased, but with decreased income.

By exceeding this threshold, households exhaust the assets, labor, capital, and management attention required for the quality execution of each activity. Resources become too dispersed. Instead of a portfolio of complementary enterprises, a set of fragile, scattered projects results.

Most households in the sample operated beyond this optimal point. More than half were classified as 'medium' diversifiers, and another 14.5% as 'highly' diversified. Only about 27% were 'low' diversifiers, and 2% specialized in a single activity. Simply put, most households in this part of Zimbabwe diversify beyond the point where it becomes profitable.

The additional activities they add are mostly low-income: petty trade, temporary agricultural labor, small informal businesses. These are not missed opportunities, but survival strategies in the face of need and adversity. Households diversify not because they see a profitable opportunity, but because rain-fed agriculture alone is no longer enough to sustain them.

It was also found that subsidy beneficiaries less frequently grew cash crops such as tobacco or cotton than non-beneficiaries. These crops require a large amount of labor, and the Pfumvudza program itself is labor-intensive. More commercially oriented farmers seem to completely opt out of the subsidy program. By absorbing labor, the program may displace cash crops that offer the most obvious path to higher income.

The key takeaway is that the profitability of diversification is determined not by the number of activities, but by the assets underpinning them. A specific group of assets was identified that predicted higher income: higher education, livestock ownership, access to irrigation, formal credit, contract farming, and regular contact with agricultural extension services.

Households possessing these assets tend to diversify into high-value activities such as tobacco, horticulture, and stable non-agricultural enterprises. Households lacking such assets engage in what is readily available, which usually yields low margins and is unstable.

These assets were concentrated among households that were initially in a better financial position. It is precisely those households that the subsidy program should help that are least able to turn subsidized resources into a source of high income.

This paradox is described in the article as 'more becomes less.' Subsidies expand livelihood portfolios but simultaneously push households further beyond the income-optimizing threshold, scattering scarce resources across activities that suppress rather than increase income. In this context, subsidies function as a coping mechanism, not a pathway out of poverty.

The findings point to several priority areas. Firstly, irrigation infrastructure needs expansion. According to the data, this is the most consistent factor ensuring high-return diversification. Reconstructing existing systems through public-private partnerships, coupled with water resource management training and crop selection, could help.

Secondly, contract farming in the tobacco and horticultural sectors should be strengthened. Pricing must be transparent, and small farmers must have legal protection against exploitative conditions.

Thirdly, investment is needed in livestock support, especially community-level veterinary services and dipping facilities. This protects one of the household's key assets.

None of this is a reason to abandon resource subsidies. It is a reason to stop viewing subsidies as an isolated livelihood strategy. Without additional investment in assets that enable high-income activities, subsidies risk creating a situation where households work harder, engage in more, but earn less.

Diversification itself is not a virtue. Whether it lifts a household up or traps it depends on the resources the household has to work with, and whether policy helps build those assets, or merely helps people cope in the absence of those assets.

Study shows: Economic benefit of cheap fertilizers for farmers decreases due to strain on the country
Read more
www.aajtak.in

Study shows: Economic benefit of cheap fertilizers for farmers decreases due to strain on the country

India's Green Revolution helped the country transition from food deficit to self-sufficiency in grain production through the use of improved seeds, irrigation, and chemical fertilizers. However, decades later, a new question has arisen for Indian agriculture: is the economic benefit derived by farmers from the excessive use of chemical fertilizers truly beneficial for the entire nation?

Various reports on topics such as agricultural health and energy were published during the COP 31 summit, which began in Turkey. A new study, 'The Economics of Cultivation' by the organization Climate Trending, asserts that the hidden costs of agriculture are rising due to the subsidization of chemical fertilizers, their unbalanced use, and dependence on imports. The report also proposes policy changes to support organic and natural farming.

According to the Climate Trends study, although farmers gain a tangible economic benefit from using chemical fertilizers, the real economic benefit for the country significantly diminishes when state subsidies, greenhouse gas emissions, and environmental damage are taken into account.

The study analyzed the agricultural sector of eight states, including Punjab, Haryana, Uttar Pradesh, Bihar, Madhya Pradesh, Chhattisgarh, Andhra Pradesh, and Karnataka.

1. Carbon Emissions from Nitrogen Fertilizers

The production of chemical nitrogen fertilizers relies on fossil fuels such as natural gas and coal. According to the report, the entire supply chain for nitrogen fertilizers generates globally 1.13 gigatons of CO2e. This accounts for about 2.1% of global greenhouse gas emissions. Of this, 38.8% of emissions come from fertilizer production, 58.6% from nitrous oxide emissions in the fields, and 2.6% from transportation. This demonstrates that the impact of chemical fertilizers on the environment is not limited to factories but also contributes to climate change through their use in the fields.

2. Farmer Profit vs. Real National Economic Benefit

The most important finding of the report highlights the difference between the farmer's private income and the socio-economic benefit to the country. In five studied cases of wheat production, it was found that the socio-economic benefit was 36% to 182% lower than the farmer's private profit, with an average difference of about 90%. For example, in Punjab (2019-20), the net private profit for the farmer was ₹31,901 per hectare, while estimated subsidy costs and emissions amounted to ₹11,554, and the net social benefit for the country was ₹20,347. Thus, while the farmer sees a profit of ₹31,901, the real benefit for the country after deducting public and environmental costs is ₹20,347.

3. High Burden of Subsidies on Punjab and Haryana

In India, during the 2021-22 period, the estimated financial burden on the government for chemical fertilizers was ₹3,630 per hectare. In Haryana, this amount reached ₹5,198, and in Punjab, it was ₹6,283 per hectare. However, in Punjab, this burden increased to ₹14,072 per hectare in 2022-23. This means that in 2022-23, the estimated financial burden in Punjab was approximately 3.88 times higher than the national average for 2021-22. This figure indicates growing financial pressure on the government due to an agrarian system heavily reliant on chemical fertilizers, and it also increases the sensitivity of the state budget to fluctuations in international fertilizer prices.

4. Subsidy Policy Stimulated Unbalanced Use of Nitrogen Fertilizers

According to the report, the Nutrient Based Subsidy (NBS) policy, introduced in 2010, caused an imbalance in the fertilizer market. Although phosphates and potash were included in NBS, the price of urea remained controlled. As a result, the share of nitrogen was 63.9% in 2007-08, then dropped to 58.8% in 2009-10, and rose to 69.9% in 2012-13. After 2010, the annual change in the nitrogen share increased by 4.42 percentage points. In Punjab and Haryana, the ratio of nitrogen to potassium was 21:1 and 20:1, respectively, while the national average was 5:1. The report suggests that the policy supporting a relatively low price for urea distanced farmers from balanced fertilizer use.

5. Dependence on Imports Persists Despite Fertilizer Production Growth

India is the second-largest fertilizer producer in the world, accounting for about 20% of global production volume. Nevertheless, India remains dependent on other countries for many essential fertilizers and raw materials used in their production. According to the report, urea production in India grew from 22.7 million tons in 2013-14 to 30.7 million tons in 2024-25. During the same period, the joint production of DAP and NPK increased from 11 million tons to 15.9 million tons. Despite this, the country imports large volumes of fertilizers. In 2022-23, India imported about 10.2 million tons of urea and 6.7 million tons of DAP, and covers about 90% of its phosphate rock needs through imports. Regarding potash, India is completely dependent on other countries.

Popular