Tata Sons Board Members to Visit Air India Headquarters to Assess Performance on November 19
Read more
Business Standard
business-standard.com

Tata Sons Board Members to Visit Air India Headquarters to Assess Performance on November 19

According to sources, members of the Tata Sons board of directors, including Chairman N Chandrasekaran and Noel Tata, plan to visit the Air India headquarters in Gurugram on Thursday. During the visit, they will review the financial performance of the airline, which is currently operating at a loss.

Air India is a joint venture between Tata Sons and Singapore Airlines, which holds a 25.1 percent stake. The CEO and Managing Director of the airline, Teoohde Gebremariam, is expected to present the company's operational report to the board members. Furthermore, operational integration between Air India and Air India Express is likely to be discussed.

Among the visitors to the Air India headquarters on Thursday will be Tata Sons Chairman Chandrasekaran, board member Noel Tata, and others. It was noted that it was not immediately possible to determine whether all members of the Tata Sons board of directors would participate in this trip.

Other members of the Tata Sons board include Venugopal Srinivasan, Harish Manwani, Anita Marangoli George, and Saurabh Agrawal. Air India has not commented on the planned visit by the Tata Sons board members.

The impact of numerous negative factors, such as rising fuel prices and the closure of Pakistani airspace, has affected long-haul flights, leading to an increase in Air India's losses to over 22,000 crore rupees in the fiscal year 2025-26. Air India was acquired by the Tatas from the government in January 2022 and is undergoing an ambitious transformation. Gebremariam took office as CEO and Managing Director on October 1.

On November 11, Singapore Airlines (SIA) reported that Air India has made tangible progress in its multi-year transformation program, including improving customer service quality and operational metrics. SIA stated that both partners continue to collaborate closely to support Air India's path to profitable growth, which includes strengthening structural cost efficiency, unlocking synergies between Air India and Air India Express, refining the commercial strategy to overcome current external challenges, and enhancing customer offerings.

In an effort to change the situation, Gebremariam stated on November 3 that Air India will rebalance its network, work on regaining market share in international markets, reduce costs, and order more wide-body aircraft. He also noted that the Air India group will grow in both full-service and low-cost operations. Gebremariam emphasized that greater growth may come from full-service operations, as the opportunities in this area are significantly larger, while Air India Express, on the LCC side, is also seeing growth, and the company aims to position these brands for customers across all market segments.

Meanwhile, Noel Tata expressed disagreement with Chandrasekaran's reappointment as chairman on several issues, including the critical matter of Tata Sons listing. Noel Tata's concerns also include the financial results of certain projects, such as the digital division, Air India, and the electronics business, during Chandrasekaran's tenure since 2017.

Similar stories

Petition in Bombay High Court demands Reserve Bank of India directives on listing of Tata Sons shares
Read more
business-standard.com

Petition in Bombay High Court demands Reserve Bank of India directives on listing of Tata Sons shares

A petition has been filed in the Bombay High Court demanding directions from the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) regarding the necessity of listing the shares of Tata Sons Private Limited on the Bombay Stock Exchange (BSE) and the National Stock Exchange (NSE). The plaintiffs argue that keeping the company as an unlisted private entity contradicts public interest.

As part of this lawsuit, lawyers Rohini Amin and L Ramanathan are also seeking the removal of Noel Tata from leadership positions in Tata Trusts and as a director of Tata Sons. Furthermore, they insist on developing a scheme to regulate the activities of Tata Sons and Tata Trusts.

The matter is scheduled for hearing in the High Court on December 2nd to decide on its admissibility.

Arguments and Grounds of the Suit

The plaintiffs base their position on the fact that approximately 67 percent of Tata Sons belongs to Tata Trusts—public charitable foundations established to support philanthropic activities, including healthcare, education, and aid for the underprivileged. They contend that since the ultimate beneficiaries of these trusts are citizens, the assets of the Tata group cannot be considered purely private property.

According to the petition, the conversion of Tata Sons from a public to a private company in September 2017 was done without consulting or considering the opinion of the trust beneficiaries. Although the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) in Mumbai approved this change on July 9, 2018, the plaintiffs questioned the process that led to this decision.

They point out that the NCLT's decision was challenged in the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT) and subsequently reached the Supreme Court in a dispute concerning former Chairman of Tata Sons Cyrus Mistry. Nevertheless, the plaintiffs assert that the interests of the public, who are the ultimate beneficiaries of Tata Trusts, were never represented or considered during these proceedings.

The petition also argues that the Supreme Court's ruling in the Cyrus Mistry case cannot serve as a precedent (res judicata) against the plaintiffs, as they did not participate in that process.

Listing Requirements and Regulatory Issues

The plaintiffs further state that Tata Sons, being the principal investment company classified as a top-tier Non-Banking Financial Company (NBFC-UL), is obligated to list its shares according to the RBI's scale-based regulatory system. They argue that the company failed to meet the listing requirement despite having assets exceeding 2 lakh crore rupees.

Additionally, the plaintiffs accuse the RBI of inaction regarding their appeals for regulatory intervention under Sections 45ID and 45IE of the Reserve Bank of India Act. These provisions were used to demand measures against the company's directors and board of directors.

The suit also raises issues of jurisdiction of the NCLT and the Charity Commissioner in resolving complaints. The plaintiffs request declarations clarifying the powers of civil courts and the Charity Commissioner on this matter.

Interim Measures and Concerns

As an interim measure, the plaintiffs seek an injunction preventing Noel Tata from proceeding with the proposed merger of Tata Electronic Systems Solutions Limited and Tata Consulting Engineers Limited with Tata Sons. They fear that the proposed restructuring could change Tata Sons' classification as a principal investment company and NBFC, potentially allowing it to bypass the mandatory listing requirement.

Tata Sons continues to be registered as a private limited company, and its annual report for the financial year 26 shows that its shares are not traded on any recognized stock exchange.

[ ]

Popular