Is it necessary to try to slow down the natural process of aging, despite its inevitability?
Read more
Super Abril
super.abril.com.br

Is it necessary to try to slow down the natural process of aging, despite its inevitability?

The question arises: if aging is a natural process, shouldn't we try to slow it down instead of letting it proceed as it may?

A philosophical approach to this topic is illustrated by an analogy with a society that is forced to give thousands of people to a ravenous dragon every day. For centuries, residents tried unsuccessfully to defeat this dragon, eventually stopped questioning methods of combat, and began justifying its existence, considering it part of the natural order, an inevitable evil, or even a necessity.

Philosopher Nick Bostrom used this parable to question our resignation in the face of aging and, to a lesser extent, death. The essence of this story is quite uncomfortable: when we cannot change something, we tend to find reasons to accept it, even if it entails certain losses.

We view aging as an inevitable biological state that we must treat as human beings. However, there is a positive aspect to this: it brings valuable experience and knowledge that is lacking in youth. Although it seems reasonable (and desirable) to clinically treat age-related diseases such as cancer, paradoxically, we look negatively on the use of technologies aimed at treating the aging process itself.

But if aging is a major risk factor for age-related pathologies and it can be modified, one can assume that slowing down this process will delay these diseases. This is the basis of the hypothesis of gerontology, which studies the biological mechanisms of aging and its connection to chronic diseases. Its immediate goal is to increase life expectancy in good condition. If this is what we desire, then it is obvious.

However, doubts arise here. Do we want to preserve aging or eliminate it? Does intervening in aging mean neglecting the elderly?

To examine this topic thoroughly, we must first dispel three established social myths. Biologist Leonard Hayflick argued that we describe aging through five characteristics: natural, normal, universal, inevitable, and irreversible. This leads to the conclusion that aging should not be considered a disease and is actually part of our lives.

Nevertheless, it is not so obvious that aging cannot be understood as a disease. Nature also gives us infections, tumors, and other conditions that we try to prevent. The fact that a phenomenon is common does not mean it is healthy. For example, caries is very common, and no one thinks that because of this we should stop treating it. The question is whether biological aging, like diseases, implies a progressive deterioration of numerous functions, which ultimately leads to death.

In this debate about whether aging is a disease, we must also consider that 'disease' is not a label with eternal boundaries that is independent of scientific achievements. Its meaning also depends on our knowledge, medical practices, and therapeutic goals.

If aging can be viewed as a disease (or at least raises doubts in us), and diseases are bad, then it seems we have grounds to want to eliminate or at least mitigate it.

Another obstacle to this analysis is that scientist Aubrey de Grey named the status quo: aging has always existed and seems inevitable, so we consider it part of the natural order of things. As the parable of the tyrannical dragon shows, becoming accustomed to damage does not turn it into something good. We rejoice when treatment prevents premature death, but we are suspicious of the possibility of significantly extending life through interventions in aging. Why should we positively evaluate some extra years of health and suspect others?

Part of this aversion stems from a misconception illustrated by the Greek myth of Tithonus: this Trojan prince achieved immortality but not youth, and was doomed to deteriorate infinitely until he turned into a miserable cricket. Philosopher Francis Fukuyama called this 'global senescence': people live very long lives but in poor health.

Gerontology researches in order to guide us in the opposite direction, that is, to weaken the biological processes that contribute to the occurrence of diseases and loss of abilities.

It is often said that aging gives us knowledge, experience, and wisdom, among other positive aspects. Aging also brings valuable benefits, such as enjoying grandchildren or maintaining long-term loving and friendly relationships. But this statement hides a paradox: how can a process that we also attribute pain, illness, and decline to be desirable?

In the article co-authored with Gonzalo Díaz-Cobacho, we discuss how this contradiction becomes clear when distinguishing between two types of aging. On the one hand, there is chronological aging, which reflects the time lived (hours, minutes, and seconds since birth). On the other hand, biological aging refers to functional deterioration of the body. Both are mixed in specialized literature and public consciousness, but their distinction is of great importance.

Accumulated experience and life wisdom depend on our life experience and the time lived, not on the damage to our cells and molecules. Therefore, intervention in biological aging does not affect chronological aspects: it is possible to gain life experience without suffering from this deterioration. Adding another year of life does not guarantee greater wisdom either: one can learn much from experience, but also little.

Furthermore, biological aging has two types of negative effects: direct and indirect. Direct ones include pain or cognitive and physical limitations caused by aging, which worsen a person's well-being. Indirect ones occur when these limitations hinder the development of projects that the elderly person considers valuable. Arthritis can cause suffering, but it can also prevent a person from walking, traveling, or continuing to pursue a favorite hobby. Does the elderly person play dominoes because they love it, or because they can no longer immerse themselves in deep waters? Why not give them the opportunity to choose what they consider the best life plan, and make sure their health is not so limiting?

Philosopher Christopher Wrather pointed out two problems in the traditional approach to aging from an ethical point of view. The first is studying it as if it only happens at the end of life, when in reality it is a gradual process. The second is that we often talk about the elderly as objects requiring attention, expenses, or care, rather than as subjects with desires, preferences, and the ability to make decisions.

The ethics of aging should not be limited to the question of 'what we do' with the elderly. It should also ask 'what they want' to do, what opportunities they have, and what lifestyles they want to maintain or adopt. And this is precisely the central idea that guides research in gerontology: it does not seek to assert that the elderly are worthless, but rather that biological aging is a disabling process that entails pain and suffering and hinders the life projects of the elderly.

Thus, the assertion that biological deterioration is undesirable is not equivalent to the assertion that the elderly are less valuable. Mixing these concepts is as problematic as romanticizing pain or fragility under the idea of dignified aging. Similarly, policy to prevent disabling pathologies does not mean that people who already suffer from them are less valuable. On the contrary, it is believed that the biological condition they face hinders the realization of their life plans.

However, individualized medical response is also insufficient. In a recent paper, we argued that well-being has individual and social dimensions. Maintaining cognitive and physical abilities can facilitate the realization of our projects, but no cellular or molecular intervention alone eliminates loneliness, age discrimination, or economic inequality. We understand that aging is conceptualized in a social context.

It is also possible that some achievements, if available only to a few or if they enhance the fetishism of youth, could generate new forms of discrimination. Therefore, biomedical research must be accompanied by policies and institutions that protect the rights, autonomy, and social recognition of the elderly.

The conclusion is quite simple: we must separate what we often confuse. Biological aging is a process that should be studied to attempt to change it under certain conditions; old age is a stage of life that can contain valuable experience; and the elderly are primarily people, not a sum of deteriorations.

Similar stories

Why is the idea of living without a predetermined plan gaining popularity among Generation Z?
Read more
www.aajtak.in

Why is the idea of living without a predetermined plan gaining popularity among Generation Z?

It was once considered necessary to create a detailed plan for any major life decision: when to finish studying, when to start working, when to buy a house, and what to do next. However, today there is a shift in this worldview among Generation Z. Many young people prefer to let events unfold rather than follow a rigid plan. This concept is also known as 'going with the flow.'

This does not mean that Generation Z is not concerned about its future. On the contrary, many young people want to remain open to new opportunities instead of fixing all aspects in advance. For them, achieving all goals, such as having a job by age 25, getting married by 30, and buying a house within set deadlines, is not mandatory. They strive to make decisions based on their needs and preferences.

To understand this trend, it is important to consider how modern young people view life. Although they may outwardly appear to be moving without a clear direction, there is a certain philosophy behind it. They prefer to live freely, gain new experiences, and change their decisions depending on circumstances.

Many members of Generation Z want to move toward their goals gradually, rather than planning the entire path in advance. It is not necessary for every step to be predetermined; they are ready to embrace new opportunities that arise along the way. This is why they might decide to change careers, move to a new place, or start a new project.

Another reason may be the growing uncertainty in life. It is becoming increasingly difficult to get answers to questions about whether one will find a job after graduation, how far their career will advance, and what changes will occur in the future. Under such conditions, some young people prefer to focus on the present instead of taking on the pressure of everything.

Nevertheless, life without a plan does not mean irresponsibility. Many young people take their careers, finances, and future seriously, but they do not want to tie their entire lives to a strict schedule. They are also willing to adjust their plans if necessary.

Study shows that water fluoridation does not affect cognitive functions in the elderly
Read more
nplus1.ru

Study shows that water fluoridation does not affect cognitive functions in the elderly

Colleagues Vinaya Sharma from Trinity College Dublin conducted a large-scale population cohort study. They found that exposure to fluoridated tap water throughout life does not lead to a decline in cognitive abilities in older adults.

The study analyzed data from 2495 people participating in the Irish longitudinal study TILDA. The average age of these participants was 65.3 years, and 57.3 percent of them were women.

The researchers assessed both the total cumulative exposure to fluoridation over a lifetime and its impact during the first five years of a person's life. To do this, they compared information on residency history in various areas with official national data regarding monitoring fluoride levels.

Cognitive function assessment was performed using standardized MMSE and MoCA scales. The results were officially presented in the scientific journal Journal of Dental Research.

Popular