You may have encountered a situation where when ordering the same product through the same online platform, the price is displayed differently on various devices. Today, there are many factors influencing the formation of these prices, among which dynamic pricing holds a special place.
A journalistic piece prepared by Olhar Digital, in collaboration with specialists, discusses these mechanisms and also analyzes what Brazilian legislation provides regarding dynamic pricing. Furthermore, the pricing policies of leading digital platforms operating in Brazil were examined.
In the early stages of capitalism, the main variables in determining the price were considered to be production costs and the supply-demand ratio. However, with technological advancements, companies added a third variable—data. Thanks to the progress of artificial intelligence (AI), collecting this data has become significantly easier and faster.
Dynamic pricing, as explained by technology and innovation specialist Arthur Igreia, 'tracks supply and demand and makes real-time adjustments.' He adds that this is possible due to numerous collected indicators, including consumer habits, location, distance, and current demand, as well as time of day and day of the week.
Igreia emphasizes that it is impossible to single out one single factor responsible for the price change; everything depends on the variables used, the platform's strategy, the business model, and the context of the specific situation. A classic example is ordering a ride through Uber immediately after a concert, when demand exceeds the supply of drivers.
Lawyer Jaime du Espírito Santo Pinheiro Neto clarifies that dynamic pricing does not necessarily mean using each consumer's personal information to determine the cost. Often, fluctuations are caused by general supply and demand conditions, without individual differentiation. He notes that personalized pricing is 'legally more sensitive,' as the platform may use data on user behavior, purchase history, and preferences to provide individual offers.
The price in delivery services consists of several levels, and each has its owner. Firstly, the restaurant sets the price of the dish, and one restaurant may have different prices for the same dish in the dining room, on its own channel, and on the delivery platform, which is determined by its commercial strategy. There are also promotions, such as coupons, free delivery, or campaigns for new customers. These promotions can be offered by restaurants or platforms, sometimes simultaneously, and are segmented by purchasing behavior.
Complaints on social media and websites like Reclame Aqui about price fluctuations on digital platforms are not uncommon. For example, in February, messages about different prices for the same dish on iFood went viral. Specialist Igreia analyzes this as a reaction of people to the atmosphere of volatility.
Other cases have had serious consequences and reached court, such as the Instacart case in the USA. It concerned lawsuits over the lack of transparency in dynamic pricing algorithms and hidden fees. Customers and authorities, including the Washington Attorney General, accused the company of misleading consumers because the app showed higher prices than in physical stores and added a 'service fee' that users confused with tips.
The court intervened because Instacart did not explain to the consumer how these amounts were calculated and where the money was going. In 2022, the case concluded with a multi-million dollar settlement, in which the company agreed to change its application. At the end of 2025, a scandal erupted over algorithmic pricing testing, where AI assigned different prices to different customers for the same product. Under public pressure and government investigations, Instacart announced the complete cessation of such tests on December 22, 2025. Concurrently, the U.S. Federal Trade Commission (FTC) launched an official investigation into deceptive practices, leading to a $60 million (331 million Brazilian reais) settlement signed by a judge on January 13, 2026.
Arthur Igreia cites the transport sector as an example. Previously, the concept of constantly changing prices was mainly associated with airline tickets, to which consumers were accustomed. However, some stability was expected for other goods and services. He points out that with digitalization and increased data volume, this logic has begun to spread to many markets.
Currently, issues with dynamic and algorithmic pricing are being experienced by the airline sector in American courts. Class-action lawsuits accuse major companies of using AI and algorithms to inflate ticket prices. The central accusation is that companies such as American, Delta, United, and Southwest Airlines shared confidential data and customer search behavior data through a centralized intelligence platform. Instead of competing, they used AI to monitor competitors in real time and prevent discounts, maintaining artificially high fares.
Government investigations are also focused on 'surveillance pricing,' where the system uses passengers' personal data to issue individual bills. Regulatory bodies, such as the FTC, have demanded explanations from airlines regarding the use of AI to predict each customer's willingness to pay based on their search history and financial profile. The U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) has also joined the case, warning that coordinated use of algorithms to align prices and eliminate competition could be classified as a federal crime.
The FTC and DOJ are analyzing the companies' AI software while numerous consumer class-action lawsuits advance in American courts. Judges are currently assessing whether there is sufficient evidence that the use of these systems constitutes a 'digital cartel.' Simultaneously, regulators are preparing new rules to prohibit the use of personal data for hidden and unreasonably high pricing. Airlines defend themselves by arguing that the use of algorithms is a legitimate market practice and that there is no price collusion between competitors. They state that AI systems only analyze publicly available data (such as the number of available seats and overall demand) to adjust fares, and that prices fluctuate to avoid empty flights.
A lawyer specializing in compliance and digital law believes that dynamic pricing itself is not prohibited by Brazilian law from a legal standpoint. According to Pinheiro Neto, companies have the freedom to establish their commercial strategies and pricing policies, provided they comply with legal frameworks and consumer relations principles. He refers to the Consumer Protection Code, which requires providing clear, adequate, and accurate information about prices and contract terms, and prohibits demanding manifestly excessive advantage.
According to Neto, the consumer must constantly monitor prices. The lawyer recommends paying attention to three points: if seemingly unjustified differences, undisclosed fees, or changes after contract confirmation are found, screenshots, request recordings, and payment receipts should be saved. He also advises seeking clarification directly from the platform, filing a complaint with Procon, or using Consumidor.gov.br. If there is suspicion of improper use of personal data, rights can be exercised under LGPD against the company and, if necessary, appeal to the National Data Protection Authority (ANPD).
Olhar Digital contacted leading digital platforms to ascertain their pricing policies. One refused to comment. 99 provided its position through the Brazilian Association of Mobility and Technology (Amobitec), which stated that its members use business models aimed at balancing user demand for rides with driver supply. The ride price depends on time, distance, vehicle category, and demand level, and can vary according to the platform's commercial strategies to maintain reliability and competitiveness.