Ways to break the cycle of forest fires in Indonesia
Read more
China Dialogue
chinadialogue.net

Ways to break the cycle of forest fires in Indonesia

Forest fires in Indonesia this year have negatively affected the health and financial situation of many citizens in the country. The smoke caused by these fires has affected neighboring countries, forcing Malaysia, Singapore, and the Philippines to raise health and safety risk alerts in recent months.

Although the topic received global attention only about a month ago, by summer Indonesia was already facing severe smog as fire outbreaks increased on fire-prone islands such as Sumatra and Borneo. According to the independent monitoring platform Nusantara Atlas, between January and September, fires destroyed 1.9 million hectares of land, with most of this occurring in September. Meteorologists note that this was one of the driest Septembers in over three decades. Another million hectares burned from September to November, according to the platform to AFP.

Although the current fires are the most intense in 11 years, covering six provinces of Sumatra and Kalimantan, Indonesia has been battling serious forest fires for over four decades. The great fire in Borneo occurred in 1982 due to severe drought and vegetation clearing using 'slash-and-burn' methods for agricultural needs, as noted by The Straits Times. Subsequent years also recorded major fires, but regional attention was only paid to them 15 years later, in the 1997 season, when nearly 10 million hectares burned, mainly in Sumatra and Kalimantan.

The smog spread to neighboring Malaysia, Singapore, Brunei, and Thailand, costing the region $10 billion due to impacts on transport, crops, timber, tourism, and healthcare, according to the World Resources Institute (WRI). Although regional action plans were developed shortly after, fires continued to occur in 2005, 2006, 2013, 2014, 2015, 2019, 2023, and this year.

Serious forest fires damage health and finances, and strain diplomatic relations. Complex factors are responsible for these fires and their prevention. During this year's fire season, as in many previous ones, peatland vegetation dominated. According to Kompas, protected peatlands accounted for half of all burned territory in Indonesia from January to September.

Indonesia owns almost 36% of the world's peatlands. These lands, composed of organic matter saturated with water for centuries, cover more than 24 million hectares in the country and are considered huge carbon sinks. In their natural state, peatlands are waterlogged, making them resistant to fire under normal weather conditions. However, when drained, degraded, or dried out, peat becomes highly flammable.

Peatlands are usually cleared for the production of palm oil, timber, and other export-oriented goods. Peat fires smolder underground, allowing them to spread unnoticed and making them difficult to extinguish. They release accumulated carbon dioxide and emit dangerous smog. WRI notes that almost all fires in Indonesia are caused by human activity.

The 1997 fires were exacerbated by the 'Mega-Rice' project, which aimed to convert one million hectares of peat into rice fields in Central Kalimantan. The Suharto regime launched this project a year earlier to support the country's growing population. Canals were dug to drain the water for planting rice. Then, to clear the forest, farmers used the cheap and fast 'slash-and-burn' method. Combined with a prolonged dry season triggered by extreme El Niño that year, this burning practice led to uncontrolled underground peat fires, which spread unchecked. Due to its persistently dry state, the area of the former 'Mega-Rice' project has since become an epicenter of regular fires in this province.

Fires intensify during the dry season, from June to October, especially in El Niño years. Indonesian legislation banned land clearing by burning in 2009. However, in 2019, a government minister stated in the media that over 80% of the country's oil palm plantations 'do not comply with applicable standards.'

El Niño and global warming have worsened the forest fire problem. In November, scientists discovered that global warming caused by fossil fuel burning raised the temperature by 1.6°C during the peak fire season, from August to October, further drying out the land and vegetation, as reported by The Guardian. El Niño added another 0.3°C and reduced rainfall by approximately 50%, the same publication noted.

During the peak period this year, forest fires in Indonesia caused serious damage to public health and led to major economic shocks both domestically and in surrounding areas. The Center for Energy and Clean Air reported that between August and September, air pollution-related mortality increased by 42%, rising from approximately 3,740 to 5,310 people nationwide.

Air quality monitoring stations in the Philippines, including the capital Manila, recorded 'unhealthy' levels of PM2.5. This fine particulate pollution, about 30 times thinner than human hair, is particularly dangerous when inhaled. Some areas of Mega Manila closed schools, as did Malaysia. Meanwhile, Singapore provided medical subsidies to those suffering from asthma, bronchitis, and other respiratory complications as air pollution increased.

Transboundary smog can also worsen the mental health of affected populations. A 2025 study linked short-term exposure to smoke during the California wildfire season in 2020 with increased emergency room visits for anxiety, depression, and mood disorders.

Smog has taken on a political dimension. On October 16, Singapore sent a notification to seven companies in Indonesia allegedly responsible for the forest fires. It demanded that they submit a plan to mitigate their activities to the Singaporean environmental agency. A little over a week later, the Indonesian government cut liquefied natural gas exports to Singapore by about 9%. This followed the Indonesian Minister of Energy, Bahril Lahadalia, allegedly warning that he 'would not hesitate to stop exports to countries that do not respect Indonesia.' Although many viewed this as a retaliatory move, Lahadalia denied it, explaining the export reduction as technical maintenance shutdowns and domestic demand.

In Malaysia, hundreds of citizens reported boycotting Indonesian products due to the smog and statements by Indonesian politicians. Syed Saddiq Syed Abdul Rahman, a MP from Muara, called on Malaysian and Singaporean banks to reduce financing for companies involved in forest fires, reports The Straits Times.

Many measures have been implemented over the years to curb forest fires in Indonesia. In 2002, ASEAN member states signed an agreement on transboundary haze. This legally binding treaty aims to prevent and monitor haze, as well as mitigate the effects of forest and land fires. Countries committed to responding promptly to information requests from other affected states and taking legislative, administrative, and other measures. Indonesia was the last country to ratify it, in 2014.

After the 2015 fires, President Joko Widodo's administration established the Peatland and Mangrove Restoration Agency (BRGM), and in 2019, made the moratorium on issuing licenses for logging in primary forests and peatlands permanent. In September 2026, his successor, Prabowo Subianto, established a new agency to replace BRGM following discussions with scientists on forest and peatland fire management. The National Peatland and Mangrove Management Agency reports directly to the president, Tempo reported.

Indonesian courts have ruled against several corporate concession holders for failing to prevent or control fires on their land, based on the principle of strict liability, which disregards intentions or preventive efforts. However, companies responded with lengthy legal appeals or delays in paying civil damages ordered by the court for environmental restoration.

Law enforcement agencies are using more modern technological means to investigate fires and hold parties accountable, such as satellite verification. This month, representatives of the National Disaster Mitigation Agency announced the creation of a mapping system that links satellite fire tracking with land concession permits.

In 2023, ASEAN members committed to achieving a haze-free Southeast Asia by 2030. Their second roadmap includes strategies such as strengthening the implementation of the 2002 agreement, sustainable management of agricultural lands and peatlands to prevent fires, and strengthening relevant laws. However, unlike the legally binding 2002 agreement, this is only a guiding framework.

Some experts believe that breaking the cycle requires more significant and sustainable funding for frontline fire prevention capabilities, supported by collective action. It is important to note that 'any such assistance must respect the sovereignty of Indonesia and its primary responsibility for preventing fires on its territory,' states Margaret Sembiring, a researcher at Nanyang University in Singapore. Without such actions and considerations, the cycle of forest fires and smog will continue.

Similar stories

Invisible Health and Environmental Risks Associated with Festivals in India
Read more
timesofindia.indiatimes.com

Invisible Health and Environmental Risks Associated with Festivals in India

Festivals in India bring people together through music, colors, food, and public celebrations. These events are an integral part of the country's social and cultural life, including fireworks displays, house decorations, color play, processions, and gatherings by rivers. However, as the scale of celebrations grows, so does their impact on the environment.

Pollution generated during festivals is often viewed in isolation, especially when air quality deteriorates after Diwali. Nevertheless, the ecological impact of these festivities is much broader: fireworks release particulate matter into the atmosphere, synthetic dyes can contaminate water bodies with chemicals, mass gatherings generate plastic waste, and loud music and fireworks contribute to noise pollution.

These consequences are not limited to any single festival or community. The use of disposable materials, increased consumption, transportation costs, decorative lighting, and improper waste disposal during various celebrations place an additional strain on nature. As a result, festive events leave behind plastic waste, chemical residues, and firework debris that pollute the air, water, and soil.

The effects can be felt far beyond the days of the festivals, affecting public health, urban sanitation, water quality, and local ecosystems. In cities already facing issues from industrial emissions, vehicle smoke, construction dust, and untreated sewage, the added burden complicates environmental management.

Diwali is one event where the link between festivals and air pollution becomes particularly evident. Fireworks release a mixture of gases, suspended particles, and chemical compounds into the atmosphere. Their emissions include particulate matter such as PM2.5 and PM10, sulfur dioxide, and nitrogen oxides. Depending on the composition, fireworks can also emit metallic compounds, including barium and aluminum.

PM2.5 is of particular concern—particles measuring 2.5 micrometers or smaller. These particles are small enough to penetrate deep into the lungs, reaching the alveoli—the tiny air sacs where oxygen enters the bloodstream. Some pollutants can enter the bloodstream and cause inflammation.

PM2.5 particles penetrate deep into the lungs, triggering inflammation and posing risks to the respiratory and cardiovascular systems. Dr. Abhishek Agrawal, a healthcare worker at a government hospital, explains how exposure to fireworks emissions affects respiratory health.

Agrawal notes: 'During festivals like Diwali, the concentration of pollutants in the air can increase due to fireworks emissions. People inhale these pollutants, especially fine particulate matter, which can penetrate deep into the lungs and cause irritation and inflammation of the airways. We often observe complaints of coughing, throat irritation, shortness of breath, and exacerbation of respiratory symptoms during periods of poor air quality.'

The impact is not uniform across all population groups. Children, the elderly, and individuals with pre-existing respiratory conditions are particularly vulnerable to sudden changes in air quality. Agrawal emphasized: 'Children, the elderly, and people suffering from asthma, COPD, or other respiratory diseases are especially vulnerable. Their respiratory systems may not cope with the sudden exposure to high levels of pollution. Even people without chronic respiratory diseases can experience discomfort, especially if pollution levels remain elevated for several hours.'

The problem can persist even after the celebrations end. During the post-monsoon period, low wind speed, atmospheric stability, and temperature inversions hinder the rapid dispersion of pollutants. When firework emissions combine with existing sources such as vehicle exhaust, industrial emissions, and construction dust, pollution levels can remain high.

Agrawal adds: 'The effects of pollution do not necessarily disappear as soon as the fireworks stop. Fine particles can remain suspended in the atmosphere, depending on weather conditions. People may continue to experience coughing, throat irritation, wheezing, and difficulty breathing in the following days. Those with respiratory diseases should exercise extra caution.'

Air pollution is not just a respiratory issue. Exposure to particulate matter, chemical emissions, and excessive noise can affect several organs, including the heart, brain, and nervous system. While the lungs are the first point of contact for inhaled pollutants, fine particles can cause inflammatory reactions affecting other parts of the body.

Air pollution is linked to increased blood pressure, irregular heart rhythms, and a higher risk of cardiovascular complications, especially in people with pre-existing heart conditions. Festive events release a mixture of chemicals, particulate matter, and plastic waste that pollutes the air, water, and soil.

Agrawal explained: 'The impact of festive pollution is not limited to the lungs. Fine particulate matter, especially PM2.5, can penetrate deep into the alveoli and cause oxidative stress and inflammation. This can lead to coughing, wheezing, shortness of breath, and asthma attacks. Air pollution can also raise blood pressure, disrupt heart rhythm, and trigger cardiovascular complications, including heart attacks, in vulnerable individuals.'

The brain and nervous system can also suffer. Exposure to polluted air and excessive noise can contribute to headaches, dizziness, stress, and sleep disturbances. Long-term exposure to polluted air is also associated with negative outcomes for cognitive health.

Chemical exposure presents another problem. Certain toxic metals and chemical residues released by fireworks and other festive materials can pose a risk to organs such as the kidneys and liver, depending on the substance, concentration, and duration of exposure.

Noise pollution adds another aspect to the health burden. Sudden, high-intensity sounds from fireworks can cause tinnitus, temporary hearing discomfort, and, at sufficiently high levels of exposure, irreversible hearing damage.

One common misconception about festive pollution is the belief that its consequences are limited to the duration of the celebrations. However, even short-term exposure to high concentrations of pollutants can trigger health problems, especially in vulnerable individuals. People with asthma may experience sudden attacks, and those with respiratory or cardiovascular diseases may face breathing difficulties or other complications. Repeated exposure over time increases the risk of chronic health problems.

Festive pollutants spread through the air, water, and soil, entering the food chain and threatening human health and ecosystems. Agrawal noted: 'Even a few hours of exposure to high levels of pollution can trigger asthma attacks, shortness of breath, and cardiovascular complications in vulnerable individuals. Repeated exposure increases the risk of long-term health problems. The duration of symptoms depends on the level of exposure and the individual's health status. Some people may recover within a few hours, while others may continue to experience symptoms for several days.'

The consequences are also reflected in the demand for medical care. Indian studies examining air pollution during and after Diwali have recorded an increase in respiratory complaints, visits, and hospitalizations, particularly related to asthma exacerbations and breathing difficulties. Agrawal added: 'Studies in India have reported an increase in hospitalizations and hospital visits for respiratory diseases after Diwali, especially related to asthma attacks, shortness of breath, and other respiratory complaints. Hospitals and medical facilities also receive cases related to burns, eye injuries, and hearing problems during festive periods.'

While attention is focused on air pollution, other forms of environmental degradation often go unnoticed during festivals. For example, the use of synthetic dyes during celebrations creates problems for water bodies and soil. Some commercially available dyes may contain chemical compounds and heavy metals that cause skin irritation, allergic reactions, and vision problems. When washed away, these substances enter drainage systems and eventually reach rivers, lakes, and other water bodies.

Similarly, religious offerings, flowers, plastic packaging, and decorative materials discarded during mass gatherings increase water and land pollution. Rituals involving idol immersion, which include plaster, synthetic paints, and non-biodegradable decorations, further increase the amount of waste entering lakes and rivers.

The consequences are particularly alarming in urban areas, where water bodies are already under pressure from untreated sewage, industrial discharge, and solid waste. Additional festive waste can exacerbate existing pollution and affect aquatic ecosystems.

Large public celebrations and processions also generate significant amounts of disposable plates, plastic bottles, food packaging, and other items. If waste is not sorted or collected properly, it can clog drains, accumulate in public spaces, and eventually end up in nearby water bodies. The problem doesn't end with the festivals: municipal sanitation workers are often forced to clean up large volumes of discarded materials, firework remnants, food waste, and plastic packaging. Improper disposal and open burning of collected waste can contribute to further local pollution.

Another dimension of festive pollution is noise, which can affect people even in the absence of visible air quality deterioration. Fireworks, loudspeakers, musical parades, and public events can subject residential areas to excessive sound levels. Sudden explosions and prolonged exposure to loud music can interfere with sleep, concentration, and daily activities.

Repeated exposure to excessive noise can also contribute to stress, anxiety, and hearing problems. People with cardiovascular diseases, infants, the elderly, and patients recovering from illnesses may be particularly vulnerable due to the disturbance during nighttime celebrations. The impact extends to animals and urban wildlife. Pets can experience stress from sudden loud noises, while birds and other species may change their behavior in response to repeated disturbances.

The World Health Organization has linked excessive environmental noise to sleep disorders, hearing impairment, and cardiovascular risks. This makes noise pollution an important public health issue, not just an inconvenience during festivals.

Hidden Burden of Electricity Consumption and Festive Shopping Modern celebrations are also associated with a significant increase in consumption. Decorative lighting in homes, markets, and commercial establishments increases electricity demand, while shopping, gift wrapping, food delivery, and travel increase energy consumption and waste generation. Although LED bulbs consume less electricity than traditional lighting, their widespread use in residential and commercial areas can still contribute to an overall increase in demand. Festive noise from fireworks and loud music can damage hearing, disrupt sleep, cause stress, and affect heart health. Excessive artificial lighting also contributes to light pollution.

Popular