RBI appeals to Supreme Court in YES Bank bond case worth 8.415 billion rupees
Read more
Business Standard
business-standard.com

RBI appeals to Supreme Court in YES Bank bond case worth 8.415 billion rupees

The Reserve Bank of India (RBI), the central bank of India, has approached the Supreme Court requesting a review of its decision regarding the Additional Tier-1 (AT-1) bonds of YES Bank, where the highest court overturned the write-off of these bonds.

According to the Supreme Court website, the central bank of India filed the petition for review on November 13. This statement by the RBI followed YES Bank's announcement last week about its appeal to the apex court seeking a review of the October 15 decision under Article 137 of the Indian Constitution.

Appeal Process

In its October 15 ruling, the Supreme Court upheld the Bombay High Court's order, which annulled the write-off of AT-1 bonds worth 8.415 crore rupees belonging to YES Bank, which were written off in March 2020. The court ruled that the bank's administrator acted beyond their authority and contrary to applicable regulatory framework. Furthermore, the court dismissed appeals filed by YES Bank, RBI, and the Union Government against the Bombay High Court's decision that cancelled the write-off.

The court determined that the administrator could not reduce the value of the AT-1 bonds after the final restructuring scheme came into effect on March 13, 2020, as the government excluded a provision directly permitting such a write-off from the approved scheme.

The dispute concerns two issuances of AT-1 bonds: one worth 3,000 crore rupees with a coupon rate of 9.5 percent, issued in December 2016, and another worth 5,415 crore rupees with a 9 percent coupon, issued in October 2017. Additional Tier-1 bonds are a type of bank debt instrument designed to absorb losses in case of creditor financial distress.

Previously, YES Bank wrote off these instruments in March 2020 following the creditor's restructuring, which faced an increasing number of bad loans, management issues, and deteriorating financial condition.

The bondholders' representative, Axis Trustee Services, challenged this write-off in the Bombay High Court in May 2020. The High Court ruled in favor of the bondholders in January 2023, a decision subsequently confirmed by the Supreme Court on October 15 of this year.

The Supreme Court's decision also addressed the payment of annual coupons on the bonds, ruling that they would remain unaffected by the appeals and must be paid according to the relevant information memorandums. After the ruling, Axis Trustee Services demanded the reinstatement of the bonds and associated rights. The trustee also requested the restoration of the instruments in the respective depository and stock exchange registries and pointed out the possibility of initiating contempt proceedings in case of alleged non-compliance.

This judgment is significant for YES Bank's capital. Previously, the creditor indicated that the reinstatement of the principal amount could impact its Common Equity Tier-1 (CET1) capital ratio by approximately 250 basis points, based on the June 2026 position. The bank also noted that the reinstatement would not affect its Tier-1 capital ratio in the same way.

Similar stories

Delhi High Court seeks responses from CBSE, central government, and NCERT regarding permission to use calculators in 12th-grade exams
Read more
www.aajtak.in

Delhi High Court seeks responses from CBSE, central government, and NCERT regarding permission to use calculators in 12th-grade exams

The Delhi High Court has sent a notice to the CBSE, demanding a response to a petition requesting permission for 12th-grade students to use simple and non-programmable calculators during board examinations. Furthermore, the court has sought clarifications from the central government, the National Council of Educational Research and Training (NCERT), and 'Parakh.'

The bench, comprising acting Chief Justice Nitin Vasudev Sambre and Judge Sanjay Sharma, has given CBSE and other parties eight weeks to present their stance and response. The next hearing in this matter before the Delhi High Court is scheduled for January 2, 2027.

During the hearing, the petitioners' lawyer informed the court that at a governing body meeting in December 2024, the CBSE agreed to allow the use of calculators in the 12th-grade accounting exam. The curriculum committee also approved this initiative in December 2024, but no concrete steps have been taken in this direction since then.

The petitioners argued before the court that due to lengthy and complex calculations, students waste valuable time. If the use of calculators is permitted, students will be able to focus on the core concepts of the subject and their own understanding, instead of spending time on manual calculations.

It should be noted that currently, this facility is provided only to a limited number of special students suffering from dyscalculia (difficulty in understanding mathematical concepts). The petition also includes a demand to expand this circle to assist other categories of students with disabilities according to their needs.

Popular