In the video game industry, which has undergone profound changes in almost three decades—with graphical evolution, larger open worlds, and new technologies—one title remains remarkably untouched: The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time, with 99 points on Metacritic.
This Nintendo classic, released on November 23, 1998, for the Nintendo 64, holds the top spot among the best-rated games in the platform's history, even after 28 years. This feat is notable, given that other highly acclaimed titles, such as Grand Theft Auto IV, Red Dead Redemption 2, Super Mario Galaxy, and The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild, have failed to surpass this score.
The discussion about this record resurfaced in 2026, driven by the release of the Ocarina of Time remake for the Nintendo Switch 2. The new version received 96 points in initial reviews, making it one of the best-rated games of the year, but falling short of the original.
Metacritic compiles reviews from specialized outlets to calculate a weighted average, known as the Metascore. The list considered in this context focuses on the highest score recorded for a version of each game, preventing repetitions of titles released on multiple platforms.
Data indicates that achieving 97 points is already an uncommon feat, and even revolutionary franchises like Grand Theft Auto, Halo, and Metroid have not reached Zelda's 99 points.
The presence of games released between the late 1990s and early 2000s also draws attention, a period characterized by the popularization of three-dimensional graphics and the consolidation of new mechanics. One reason for Ocarina of Time's prominence lies in its 1998 release. At that time, 3D games were still developing solutions for problems that seem simple today, such as camera control, exploration of complex environments, and combat in open spaces.
The Nintendo title was fundamental in establishing crucial benchmarks for action-adventure games, particularly through the Z-Targeting system, which allowed the camera to lock onto enemies and objects. The combination of elements such as exploration, puzzles, combat, and narrative contributed to the game becoming a standard for subsequent productions.
However, the game's historical relevance does not solely justify the 99 points. The result is also linked to how the reviews were aggregated. A central argument from ranking critics is the disparity in the number of reviews used to calculate the scores. Ocarina of Time has a Metascore based on only 22 specialized critical reviews.
In contrast, The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild, released in 2017, achieved 97 points with 117 reviews, while Red Dead Redemption 2 also reached 97 points with 109 reviews in the examined version. This demonstrates that the games were evaluated in very different contexts.
During the 1990s, specialized video game coverage was smaller, and fewer publications were included in these surveys. Today, major releases can receive reviews from dozens or even hundreds of outlets. A higher volume of reviews increases the chances of divergent opinions influencing the final average, although this does not mean a smaller sample guarantees a higher score.
Another relevant point is that Metacritic does not use a simple arithmetic mean; the platform applies different weights to publications based on its own editorial criteria. Furthermore, scores are segmented by platform, meaning the same game can have different ratings on PlayStation, Xbox, Nintendo Switch, or PC. For this reason, directly comparing titles separated by decades requires caution.
On Metacritic, Ocarina of Time maintains the position of the game with the highest score from specialized critics, which is a verifiable data point within the platform's methodology. However, the Metascore does not directly measure a work's cultural impact, commercial success, or player preference. A game can be historically vital to the industry without achieving a near-perfect score. Similarly, an excellent launch review does not guarantee that all its mechanics will age well.
The Ocarina of Time remake itself, released in 2026, exemplifies this distinction. Despite receiving positive reviews, its initial score fell below the original version, even with modern updates included. Thus, Ocarina of Time's 99 points reflect both the recognition of a generational milestone and the way specialized criticism evaluated video games at that time. After 28 years, the record persists, raising the question of whether experiences created in such disparate eras can be compared using only a single score.



