Questions about Elon Musk's silence regarding the Starlink ban in China after licensing issues in India
Read more
Aaj Tak
www.aajtak.in

Questions about Elon Musk's silence regarding the Starlink ban in China after licensing issues in India

The issue of Starlink licensing continues in India. Elon Musk, head of the satellite company Starlink, expressed his dissatisfaction with the lack of approval in India and made several serious accusations.

This raised the question of why Musk is not expressing similar dissatisfaction in China, where Starlink is also banned. This question was posed on the platform X by Rajiv Malhotra, a researcher and author of Indian origin.

Musk, one of the world's wealthiest individuals, has invested significant funds in Tesla's business in China, yet the Starlink service has not yet received permission there.

In his post on X, Rajiv Malhotra asked: 'Elon, why hasn't Starlink received permission in China? Could some Chinese industrialist (oligarch) be behind this? You have invested heavily in Tesla in China, but the Starlink service is blocked there.'

Earlier, on Wednesday, a post circulated on social media claiming that Musk accused 'oligarchs' (influential industrialists) of obstructing the launch of the Starlink service in India, although he did not name names.

Following this, Musk criticized Mukesh Ambani, Chairman of Reliance Industries, questioning his status as India's 'chief boss'. After Musk's post was published, Congress politician Rahul Gandhi also posted a comment on the X platform.

Malhotra explained that the Starlink problem goes beyond technology and service quality; it is also related to national sovereignty. He noted that there are many reasons for this delay.

The Indian government also responded to Musk's statements. It stated that rules in India are the same for everyone and do not allow discrimination. It was clarified that licenses for satellite communication have been issued to three companies, and all must undergo a security vetting process while awaiting final approval.

The government mentioned the three companies granted licenses: Elon Musk's Starlink, Reliance Jio satellite communication, and Eutelsat OneWeb, supported by the Bharti group.

Similar stories

Elon Musk's Starlink service is blocked in several countries, including China and Russia, sparking controversy with India
Read more
www.aajtak.in

Elon Musk's Starlink service is blocked in several countries, including China and Russia, sparking controversy with India

Disputes surrounding Elon Musk's Starlink continue, particularly concerning the United States. Musk frequently makes strong statements regarding India, to which India has also responded. However, India is not the only country where the Starlink service is unavailable.

There are numerous countries, from China to Russia, where the Starlink service is banned, and permission is pending in many others. In this context, Elon Musk's statements focusing solely on India have surprised many.

Starlink has provided information on its service availability through an official portal that includes a global map. On this map, the company indicates where the service operates, where it will soon launch, and where it is already blocked.

According to the Starlink portal data, the service is available in countries such as Canada, the USA, Brazil, Sweden, London, and Austria. In India, Pakistan, Nepal, and Iran, approval from local authorities is expected, after which the Starlink service should begin operating shortly.

Countries where the Starlink service is blocked include China, Russia, and Afghanistan, as well as Syria. In February 2026, Elon Musk announced that SpaceX had blocked its service in Russia to prevent unauthorized use of Starlink.

There is also a state restriction in Iran. Starlink has become an important topic against the backdrop of state control over internet and communication services in Iran. Many people used the Starlink service after the internet was shut down in Iran. The Starlink portal shows that the service is closed in Iran.

In January, Reuters reported in its report that due to the shutdown of the state internet in Iran, many people secretly accessed the internet using Starlink.

Why is Starlink not working in China?

China enforces strict regulations for providers of satellite internet services from abroad. The country's telecommunications and internet system is under tight state control, so Starlink could not obtain permission in China.

The Indian government has responded, stating that India's rules are the same for everyone. Furthermore, licenses have been issued to three companies, one of which is Elon Musk's Starlink. Approval regarding security is still pending.

What is Starlink?

Starlink essentially provides a high-speed internet service directly to the user, bypassing mobile towers, by using satellites. Starlink is an American company.

Musk attempts to sell Starlink in India; raises issue of banning foreign US companies
Read more
www.aajtak.in

Musk attempts to sell Starlink in India; raises issue of banning foreign US companies

SpaceX, a company owned by one of the world's wealthiest individuals, Elon Musk, has long sought to provide its Starlink satellite internet service in India. The attractiveness of the Indian market is due to the growing middle class, large population, and increasing purchasing power.

Musk claims that his Starlink has received licenses in 165 countries and that the company has met several requirements of the Indian government while preparing ground infrastructure to provide the service. Nevertheless, the Indian government has not yet approved the launch of this service.

According to one report, Starlink began attempts to operate in India in 2022. In June 2025, it was issued a license agreement for satellite communication services by the Ministry of Telecommunications. Subsequently, in September 2025, it was granted spectrum for testing. However, launching a commercial service requires completing several procedures, including obtaining security clearances.

Following recent objections from Elon Musk, the Indian Ministry of Telecommunications rejected his claims. The Ministry stated on October 8 that the satellite communication regulatory system in India is impartial and non-discriminatory. The government emphasized that Starlink is at the same stage of regulatory review as two other companies—Jio Satellite and OneWeb from Airtel.

Furthermore, on October 9, 2026, Telecom Minister Jyotiraditya Scindia announced that the process of determining the spectrum cost for satellite communication is in its final stages. If the Indian government delays issuing licenses under the pretext of security, billionaire Musk's objections become meaningless, as the state's sovereignty over national security matters is non-negotiable.

Starlink is a satellite internet service from Elon Musk's SpaceX. As the name suggests, the company provides internet access via satellites. Starlink delivers internet through a network of small satellites located approximately 550 kilometers from Earth. Unlike traditional satellite internet systems where satellites are at a much higher altitude, Starlink's satellites are relatively close to the planet's surface. This results in reduced latency when sending and receiving data, which improves services such as video calls, online gaming, and streaming video.

The main advantage of this system is that it does not depend on mobile towers or fiber optic cables laid underground. The user requires a special antenna and router that connects to the satellite to receive the internet. This allows connectivity even in mountainous regions, remote villages, maritime zones, and disaster-stricken areas. Musk calls this feature the biggest unique selling proposition (USP) of his company, arguing that it enables internet provision in hard-to-reach regions of India without laying cables.

However, such continuous internet provision raises security questions in a country like India, leading India to proceed cautiously while considering security issues. Both India and America have very strict security standards. The US has imposed strict restrictions on companies, technologies, and services related to certain countries based on national security. The American government's stance is particularly stringent regarding China's communication and surveillance technologies. US concerns stem from the possibility that foreign governments could gain access to confidential networks, government communications, and citizen data through companies from their countries and use this to their advantage.

Essentially, telecommunication networks, satellites, and internet services are not only commercial tools but are also linked to military operations, intelligence, and national security. Therefore, American politics places great importance on the nationality of the company, its ownership, and the potential influence of the associated government.

Citing national security, the US has imposed bans on many major technology companies worldwide, most of which are Chinese. China is America's main rival. The US has completely ceased using products and services from these companies in government agencies, military institutions, and critical infrastructure. Among these giants is the Chinese technology company Huawei. The US has been tightening control over this company's 5G equipment, telecommunications gear, and smartphones since 2019. American telecom companies and government agencies do not use any Huawei equipment. Furthermore, the absence of Google services in new phones has effectively removed the company from the American market.

In September 2026, Huawei stated in a New York court that the case concerned competition, not a conspiracy. The company insisted that it was about innovation, not theft, and that ordinary business operations were being portrayed as a crime. Another company, ZTE, has also been banned from selling telecommunications equipment and mobile devices. American government networks and major telecom operators do not use ZTE equipment. The production and sale of new models have been practically halted. In 2019, the Donald Trump administration placed Huawei on the 'Entity List.'

Popular