Among the youth protesting in Ranchi and holding demonstrations for the past 20 days, one main question is being raised: if the government can cancel the 14th JPSC exams and delayed exams, why is it hesitant about canceling the JSSC-CGL exam?
Recently, government representative and minister Hemant Soren, Sudivya Kumar Sonu, held extensive negotiations with student delegations. The government claims to have met '98% of student demands,' but it has categorically refused to cancel the JSSC-CGL exam, which has caused the most resonance.
The government's main argument is legal in nature. Minister Sudivya Kumar Sonu stated that the JSSC-CGL exam was conducted under the supervision and in accordance with the directives of the Supreme and High Courts. In the government's view, the regional government does not have the right to unilaterally cancel an exam when the matter is under the oversight of higher courts. Cancellation without strong legal grounds would lead to judicial review proceedings.
The second argument is that the CGL exam process has already advanced significantly: results have been published, and many successful candidates have already started working in their appointed positions. In this situation, canceling the entire exam could lead to already selected candidates filing lawsuits, halting the entire process for years.
Students demand the complete cancellation of the CGL exam and an investigation into the matter by the CBI. However, the government took the opposite stance and rejected the request for a CBI investigation. Instead, the government proposed an inquiry through the CID and suggested creating a monitoring committee chaired by a 'retired judge.' The government added that if the CID investigation finds evidence of large financial transactions, it will approach the Enforcement Directorate (ED) for an investigation, but the exam will not be canceled under any circumstances.
Protesting students (JPSC-JSSC Nyay Manch candidates) completely reject the government's arguments. Leaders of the student movements claim that the government is spreading falsehoods about meeting 98% of the demands. In fact, out of 13 disputed exams, only three were canceled (the preliminary stage of the 14th JPSC and the delayed JPSC exams of 2023 and 2025). Students believe that since there is full evidence of material leakage and fraud by the TDPL agency, canceling the exam under the pretext of court action only protects the syndicate.
>


