The commission requested medical documents after it became known that the North Western businessman, Sulaiman Karim, was allegedly seen at a shopping center in the Western Cape.
Emergence of Allegations
Lead evidence lawyer, Matthew Chaksalson, addressed the commission, demanding that Karim's doctors be required to provide his medical records. These dramatic claims surfaced on Wednesday during the Madlanga Commission hearing following the postponement of testimony from Wusimuzi 'Cat' Matlala.
Chaksalson informed the commission members that two whistleblowers independently reported seeing Karim at the shopping center, and they also claimed to have seen him during lunch.
Commission's Demands
Chaksalson noted that the commission expects to receive CCTV footage from the shopping center or Woolworths to verify these statements. These allegations arose against the backdrop of another no-show by Karim before the commission, who cited poor health.
Chaksalson argued that although the medical certificate presented on behalf of Karim explained his absence, it did not state that he was medically unfit to answer the commission's questions. He reminded the commission members that Karim had also failed to appear after receiving notification on June 17, and the commission is still awaiting a written statement with answers to its questions.
Financial Matters and Defense
Furthermore, Chaksalson informed the investigation that financial reports related to Karim's companies—Ziggy, Tasmika, and Tamiez—remain unsubmitted, adding that these enterprises received millions of rands. Karim's lawyer, Kammil Premhid, rejected these accusations, insisting that his client is undergoing hospital treatment.
Premhid stated to the commission: 'My client is in the hospital.' He emphasized that the medical professional had already explained Karim's inability to attend and cautioned against relying on unverified whistleblower information, which could unfairly damage his client's reputation. Premhid also mentioned that he only learned about the whistleblowers' statements on Wednesday, which did not allow him to properly consult with Karim before the issue was raised at the hearing. The matter was adjourned until Friday, and Premhid notified the commission of his intention to file a motion in closed session.