After the end of apartheid in 1994, South Africa made significant efforts to build a reputation as a model continental citizen. To compensate for past apartheid mistakes and express gratitude for the support of African nations during the fight against apartheid, post-apartheid South Africa actively sought the support of its neighbors.
Pan-Africanism and International Participation
The country firmly declared its African identity and became one of the most active proponents of Pan-Africanist ideals. Over the last 32 years, South Africa has participated in peacekeeping and conflict resolution missions in countries such as the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC), Burundi, Mozambique, Zimbabwe, and Madagascar, utilizing significant domestic resources.
South Africa is one of the few countries on the continent to have established the African Renaissance Fund (ARF) in 2001. Since its inception, approximately 3 billion rand has been directed towards humanitarian aid, social welfare, nation-building, and peacekeeping projects in various African states.
Role in Continental Governance
In the early 21st century, South Africa played a crucial role in shaping the new architecture of continental governance, embodied by the establishment of the African Union (AU), which replaced the Organization of African Unity (OAU). The AU and related structures, such as the New Partnership for Africa's Development (NEPAD), the Pan-African Parliament (PAP), and the African Peer Review Mechanism (APRM), were central to the concept of African renaissance promoted by former South African President Thabo Mbeki.
Economic Influence and Immigration
In its pursuit to demonstrate its Pan-African qualities, South Africa eased conditions for legal or other residency for immigrants from other African countries fleeing wars, conflicts, and poverty. Currently, the country hosts about 3.2 million international immigrants, approximately 90 percent of whom are from the continent. The country's investments in improving its continental reputation over the last three decades have yielded tangible results.
South Africa's trade turnover with the African continent grew from 11 billion rand in 1994 to 759 billion rand in 2024, achieving a significant trade surplus of 379 billion rand. This indicates success in accessing increasingly profitable African markets. South Africa is the largest source of intra-African foreign direct investment and the sixth-largest source of FDI for all of Africa, with an FDI volume exceeding $32 billion across about 40 African countries.
No other African country can compare with South Africa's economic influence on the continent. Its Development Finance Institutions (DFIs), such as the Industrial Development Corporation (IDC) and the Development Bank of Southern Africa (DBSA), have secured major contracts for infrastructure and industrial projects across the continent, fostering regional integration and the formation of regional supply chains.
Tourism and Economic Goals
Furthermore, South Africa is the most popular destination for intra-African tourism. Between 2000 and 2024, the country registered an average of nearly 6 million arrivals of African tourists, accounting for about 80 percent of the total number of tourists. According to the Department of Tourism, African tourists spent an average of 36 billion rand annually between 2015 and 2024, highlighting their vital role in sustaining tens of thousands of jobs in the tourism and hospitality sectors.
By all accounts, over the last three decades, South Africa has managed to build favorable economic relations with the rest of Africa. However, the current wave of anti-immigrant protests, considered the most intense and widespread recently, threatens to undermine the diplomatic capital South Africa has gained and weaken its economic standing on the continent.
Consequences of Protests and Diplomatic Crisis
Groups leading the protests—March and Operation Dudula—claim that immigrants are responsible for high crime rates in the country, displacing South Africans from the labor market, and competing for limited resources such as healthcare and education. The protests have led some African countries, including Lesotho, Malawi, Zimbabwe, Mozambique, Nigeria, and Ghana, to repatriate thousands of their citizens residing in South Africa following threats of violence.
Uganda is also preparing to repatriate its citizens, who, according to it, are under threat of xenophobic attacks. Hundreds of immigrants from Congo, Malawi, and Zimbabwe have been forced to seek shelter in open and overcrowded areas while awaiting repatriation. The fact that immigrants from other African countries, including children, are forced to live in open, inhumane conditions because some citizens are expelling them from their communities negatively affects South Africa's image on the continent.
The South African government has shown a greater willingness to assist with the repatriation of immigrants to their home countries than to stop their expulsion from communities. The treatment of African immigrants, who constitute 90 percent of the 3.2 million immigrants in South Africa, has provoked unprecedented diplomatic resonance, with the governments of Nigeria and Ghana openly criticizing the South African government's approach to the protests.
Nigeria's Foreign Minister, Bianca Ojukwu, characterized the actions of the anti-immigrant groups as Afrophobia, given that Black immigrants were disproportionately at risk. Ghana's Foreign Minister, Samuel Okudzeto Ablakwa, even sent an official letter to the African Union requesting that South Africa be included in the agenda of the Mid-Year Coordination Meeting held on June 24. In the letter, he expressed regret that 'targeting citizens of African countries poses a challenge to the common principles of African solidarity, brotherhood, and continental unity.' While this may have been somewhat dramatic, considering that Ghana's request to the AU was unsuccessful, it could reflect a changing perception of South Africa among African nations.
Prospects and Risks
These unpleasant events will complicate South Africa's efforts in economic diplomacy on the continent, especially as the country aims to increase exports to the continent from 569 billion rand to 1.1 trillion rand by 2030. The Department of Tourism has also set a goal of reaching 15 million African tourist arrivals by 2030. Achieving these goals in the current diplomatic climate will be a difficult task, as economic cooperation does not happen in a vacuum.
The situation also jeopardizes South Africa's unofficial status as a regional leader, which has opened many doors for it globally, allowing the country access to influential global platforms such as BRICS and the G20 due to its perceived role as an African representative. If these protests are not carefully managed, they could do more harm to South Africa's image in Africa than good.